10 Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes

If beauty is in the eyes of the beholder, it’s usually a good idea to make your eyes even more appealing than they are. One method to do this is to use a vivid eyeliner! If, on the other hand, your eyes are easily irritated, it’s time to meet the finest eyeliners for sensitive eyes.

These products have been particularly designed to be gentle on your eyes while still offering powerful color payoff without causing discomfort. The greatest thing is that they include waterproof, long-lasting, and simple-to-apply compositions, providing you a variety of possibilities.

We should be eternally thankful to the beauty business for creating items for every need, such as eyeliners that will fix all of your sensitivity issues. Take your selection from our list of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes.

It’s no secret that the cosmetics business has completely changed the beauty game, and we can’t help but be grateful for their outstanding formulations that cater to every skin type and desire. And don’t be concerned about those with sensitive eyes!

We’ve painstakingly tested and chosen some of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes, giving you the confidence to create the most gorgeous eye makeup styles. So scroll down, choose your favorite, and enjoy a stress-free beauty experience!

10 Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes

1. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eyeliner

Women struggle to get the perfect wing, but with NYX Professional Makeup’s Epic Ink Eyeliner, it’s as simple as a breeze. The slim, elastic brush tip aids in the creation of the perfect, long-lasting cat eye with a matte finish. This extremely pigmented, waterproof eyeliner also allows you to effortlessly make black liquid lines.

Each stroke is extremely fluid for a perfect finish, eliminating eye irritation. You have the option of going for a sleek and natural appearance or a wide, assertive one. By pressing down on the tip with incredible accuracy, you may regulate the thickness.

Pros

• Affordable
• Intense color
• Smudge-proof
• Professional makeup

Cons

• Tip may be too thin

2. Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner

If you enjoy nude eyeliners, this Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in the shade “Espresso” will be the only espresso you’ll ever adore except your morning cup of joe. This eyeliner is so pigmented that one stroke will stay all day. It has a built-in smudger tip that won’t break when you’re applying liner to your sensitive eyelids.

A softer, smokier effect may be achieved without the use of an extra tool. The eyeliner also has a micro-fine point for precise application. The eyeliner pencil’s finest feature is its self-sharpener, which resharpens the liner with a simple twist.

Pros

• Precision tip
• Built-in sharpener
• Long-lasting
• Dark pigment

Cons

• May not suit all complexions

3. Rimmel Scandaleyes 24 hr Eyeliner

The finest drugstore eyeliner for sensitive skin is Rimmel Scandaleyes. It is long-lasting, which means your eyes may remain undisturbed for a whole day while you rock the appearance you choose. Even if you’re a beginner, this shimmering brown eyeliner will slide on like butter and requires no preparation.

It has a creamy composition that helps to smooth out the eyelids. The eyeliner, as the name says, has a deep color that may amp up your appearance and get your eyes set to look scandalous!

Pros

• ​​Smudge-proof
• Sweat-proof
• Heat-proof
• Ophthalmologist tested

Cons

• No sharpener

4. Jane Iredale Eye Pencil – Mineral Eyeliner Pencil

Jane Iredale’s cruelty-free eyeliner pencil is filled with the benefits of nourishing ingredients such as shea butter, mango seed oil, and meadowfoam seed oil, making the eyelids feel wonderfully velvety. It contains natural colors that may be used to create strong, dramatic appearances.

It accurately defines the eyelids, making your eye makeup appear delicate and refined. The liner is a rich combination of moisturizing oils and waxes that gives a captivating, velvety texture and enhances the beauty of the eyes.

The brand’s vegan and cruelty-free recipe makes it an excellent choice for anyone searching for environmentally responsible items.

Pros

• Vegan
• Long-lasting results
• Nourishing ingredients
• Loaded with natural pigments
• Soothing effects on the eyes

Cons

• Doesn’t last long

5. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil will be your go-to eyeliner for sensitive eyes, whether you want to master the wings or a cat-eyed appearance. This cult favorite long wear pencil liner features a new waterproof formula and a smooth, creamy texture that lasts up to 24 hours.

It also has an inbuilt sharpener to assist you produce crisp lines with accuracy, making our lives easier. Revlon Colorstay is available in 8 distinct tones, each of which is highly pigmented and vivid. It’s quite affordable and a must-have if you like kohl.

Pros

• Water-proof
• Easy glide
• Lightweight formula
• Ophthalmologist tested

Cons

• Removal may be difficult

6. Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer

Our eyes are the only source of drama in our life. With this Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, you may get the dramatic eyelids you wish. The silky creamy texture of this retractable eyeliner pencil is enhanced by an inbuilt smudger for fine blending.

This one, like other new-age eyeliners, features a sharpener for highly efficient kohl strokes. Sensitive eyes require eyeliner that does not require repeated touch-ups, and this long-lasting waterproof product is ideal for wearing at work or during the day.

Pros

• Office wear
• Smooth formula
• Sharpener
• Creamy texture

Cons

• Light pigment

8. e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

The e.l.f. Cosmetics No-Budge Retractable Eyeliner is the longest lasting formula for flawless eye makeup. This eyeliner has a creamy pigmented composition that can be applied to the waterline, lash line, or lid for a sophisticated look. It’s a deal for the price and also waterproof.

Sensitive eyes are generally irritated when eyeliner is applied to the waterline, so use caution when using any product in close touch with the eye. Because the eyeliner is devoid of hydroquinone, sulfates, and parabens, you may use it on your eyelids with confidence.

Pros

• Smudge-proof
• Ultra creamy
• No toxins
• Water-proof

Cons

• No precision tip

9. Almay Liquid Eyeliner

Almay liquid eyeliner’s flexible brush and calligraphy-inspired inkwell are a powerful arsenal for defining your eyes perfectly. The design was created with the goal of achieving continuous vivid hue. Almay’s water-resistant composition may be worn for up to 16 hours without causing irritation.

Furthermore, the flexible, smear-free composition will keep the appearance intact throughout the day and will not give you raccoon eyes. This liquid liner is incredibly delicate and is ideal for people with sensitive skin and eyes. If you have trouble getting a straight line in your eyes, the flex-tip applicator will save you from making any errors.

Pros

• Ophthalmologist tested
• Hypoallergenic
• Fragrance-free
• Cruelty-free

Cons

• Less product

10. Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

This amazing eyeliner has a deep, vivid color that lasts all day without smearing or fading, ensuring that your appearance is immaculate. Furthermore, with gentle light diffusers that brighten the whites of your eyes and nourishing ingredients like olive oil and rainforest shea butter, this pencil is more than just cosmetics; it’s a must-have for every beauty aficionado.

You can also obtain a precise and defined appearance with the built-in sharpener, while the contoured smudger allows you to quickly create a soft, smokey eye that will turn attention.

Pros

• Nourishing
• Ophthalmologically-tested
• High color payoff
• Precise lines

Cons

• Difficult to sharpen

Considerations for Selecting Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

Dealing with sensitive eyes can be unpleasant at times, but in order to properly care for them, you must first understand your eyes and their demands. So, while shopping for eyeliner for your sensitive eyes, keep the following tips in mind.

Highly-pigmented Eyeliners

If you have sensitive eyes, always use highly pigmented eyeliners. Touch-ups might hurt your eyes and lead you to cry. Eyeliners with rich pigments stay a long time without fading, smudging, or drying out your eyes.

Ingredients

The ingredients list is an important but sometimes overlooked part of selecting cosmetic products. While you don’t need to know what’s in each eyeliner, it’s best to avoid harsh chemicals that irritate your eyes.

Harmful chemicals, parabens, and sulfates included in certain eyeliners can irritate sensitive eyes. Choose eyeliners free of harsh substances to safeguard your eyes from discomfort, dryness, and irritation. It is recommended to use vegan eyeliners.

Color

While the color of your eyeliner has no effect on the sensitivity of your eyes, it is best to choose a color that you would wear every day if you like wearing eyeliners with all of your clothes.

However, don’t restrict yourself to only black eyeliner; there is a wide range of eyeliner hues to pick from. You may liven up your beauty vanity with some bright hues.

Water-resistant

When it’s pouring (or you’re having an emotional breakdown), a water-resistant eyeliner comes in handy. Choose an eyeliner that will remain on even if you have to jump in the pool or wipe away sweat after a tough exercise. Whatever the weather or circumstance, as fellow beings, we always hope your eyeliner is even and your makeup is flawless.

So, waterproof eyeliner will not budge until you remove it. It is also the ideal solution for people who wear contact lenses and have regularly wet eyes. This eliminates the need to touch up dents during the day.

Thickness

The substance of eyeliners varies according to their shape. Eyeliners are often in the form of a pencil, gel, or liquid. While a gel liner is the thickest, a pen eyeliner is generally the lightest. Lightweight eyeliners are always the finest for sensitive eyes since they don’t strain your eyelids and make them feel droopy or heavy.

Applicator

The type of applicator used is critical in deciding how easily and pleasantly the eyeliner may be applied. To avoid any potential irritation or pain, use a delicate and gentle applicator. Look for alternatives with gentle and fine-tip brushes that prioritize sensitivity over standard eyeliners with harsh or stiff bristles.