As an Amazon Associate, BeautyLara earns from qualifying purchases.
Eyebrow gel is the fastest way to make brows look fuller, tidier and more polished. One or two strokes lift the hairs, set them in place and, with a tinted formula, fill in sparse spots. In this guide we compare three proven eyebrow gels, explain when to choose clear vs tinted, and walk you through an easy application routine.
Key Takeaways
- Clear gel sets brows in place without changing color; ideal if your brows are already full or dark.
- Tinted gel adds color and volume to sparse or light brows.
- Fiber gels such as Benefit Gimme Brow+ cling to hairs to make brows look thicker.
- Brush upward and outward, then tidy the tail for a natural, brushed-up look.
The Best Eyebrow Gels Compared
| Eyebrow Gel | Type | Best For | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benefit Gimme Brow+ | Tinted, fiber | Sparse brows needing volume | Mid-high |
| Essence Make Me Brow | Tinted, fiber | Budget-friendly fullness | Budget |
| RefectoCil Styling Gel | Clear, conditioning | Strong hold and tinted brows | Budget-mid |
Eyebrow Gel Reviews
Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel
Best for: Sparse or patchy brows that need color and volume
Benefit Gimme Brow+ is one of the best-known tinted brow gels. It contains tiny fibers that cling to brow hairs and the skin underneath, making brows look fuller. The small, tapered brush makes it easy to control, and it comes in a wide shade range from cool blonde to deep brown.
Pros
- Visibly fuller brows
- Precise mini brush
- Many shades
Cons
- More expensive than drugstore gels
- Fibers can flake if overapplied
Essence Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara
Best for: Budget shoppers who want a Gimme Brow-style effect
Essence Make Me Brow is often called a drugstore alternative to Gimme Brow. It also uses fibers to build volume and tint the hairs, at a fraction of the price. Hold is a little softer, but for everyday brows it does the job well.
Pros
- Very affordable
- Adds tint and volume
- Natural finish
Cons
- Fewer shades
- Hold is lighter
RefectoCil Styling Gel
Best for: Unruly brows and anyone who tints their brows
RefectoCil is best known for professional brow and lash tints. Its clear styling gel is designed to hold and care for brow hairs, and it pairs well with tinted brows because it will not shift the color. Use it after pencil or powder to lock everything in place. You can also browse the full brand range for dark eyebrows.
Pros
- Strong, clear hold
- Works over pencil and powder
- Good for tinted brows
Cons
- No color payoff on its own
Clear or Tinted Eyebrow Gel
Choose a colored eyebrow gel if your brows are light, sparse or uneven; it tints the hairs and makes them look thicker. Pick a transparent gel if your brows are full and naturally dark, or if you have already filled them with an eyebrow pencil. For a tinted gel, match your natural hair color or go one shade lighter for a soft, natural look; going darker can look harsh.
How to Apply Eyebrow Gel Step by Step
- Brush brows upward with a clean spoolie to see their natural shape.
- If needed, fill gaps with light, hair-like strokes using an eyebrow pencil.
- Wipe excess product off the gel wand on the tube rim to avoid clumps.
- Brush the gel through the brows from the inner corner upward and outward.
- Comb the tail outward and slightly downward to keep the shape clean.
- Let the gel set for a minute before touching the brows.
Quick Brow Tutorial for a Brushed-Up Look
For the trendy laminated or “soap brow” effect without a salon visit, brush the front hairs straight up with a clear gel, press them flat with a fingertip for a few seconds, then angle the middle and tail outward. A clean lash brush or spoolie helps separate hairs for a feathery finish.
Caring for Your Brows
- Remove brow gel nightly with a gentle cleanser or micellar water.
- Avoid over-plucking; let brows grow out for a few weeks before reshaping.
- Some people condition brows with castor oil at night. Evidence that it boosts growth is anecdotal, but it can make hairs look glossier. Keep oil away from your eyes.
- Replace brow gel roughly every six months to keep the wand hygienic.
For more eye makeup help, see how to find the best mascara and our guide to using a makeup sponge for a smooth base.
Looking for more options? Shop more eyebrow gels on Amazon.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is eyebrow gel better than pencil?
They do different jobs. Pencil fills gaps and draws shape; gel sets hairs and adds subtle volume. Many people use both: pencil first, then gel.
Can I use clear mascara as eyebrow gel?
Yes, clear mascara works in a pinch, but brow gels have smaller brushes and are designed for a firmer hold on brow hairs.
Which eyebrow gel shade should I choose?
Match your natural brow color or go one shade lighter. Blondes can go one shade darker than their hair for definition.
Does eyebrow gel damage brows?
No. Brow gel sits on the surface of the hair. Just remove it gently each night instead of rubbing.
How long does eyebrow gel last?
Most gels hold all day. Waterproof or strong-hold formulas last longer in heat and humidity.
Conclusion
For sparse brows, Benefit Gimme Brow+ is the best eyebrow gel overall, while Essence Make Me Brow delivers a similar effect on a budget. If you just need hold, RefectoCil Styling Gel keeps brows in place without changing their color. Brush up, set and go for polished brows in under a minute.
5 Comments