As an Amazon Associate, BeautyLara earns from qualifying purchases.
Blue mascara is one of the easiest ways to add colour to your makeup without committing to bright eyeshadow. A deep navy tint looks almost black from a distance but catches the light up close, while cobalt and electric blues make a bold statement. Below we cover the blue mascaras that are easy to find on Amazon, which shade suits which eye colour, and how to wear blue without looking costume-like.
Why Blue Mascara Works
Blue sits opposite orange on the colour wheel, so it can make the whites of the eyes look brighter and warm eye colours, like brown and hazel, look richer. Navy is the most wearable shade for daytime; brighter cobalt reads as a deliberate fashion look.
Choosing the Right Shade of Blue
| Shade | Effect | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Navy / midnight | Subtle, reads close to black | Everyday wear, office, first-timers |
| Cobalt | Noticeably blue, vibrant | Brown and hazel eyes, events |
| Electric / bright blue | Bold and playful | Festivals, editorial looks |
| Teal / blue-green | Colourful with a green cast | Brown eyes, green eyes |
If you have green eyes, also see our guide to the best mascara for green eyes, where plum and brown shades often do more than blue.
Blue Mascaras Worth Trying
These are widely available blue or blue-shade versions of well-known mascaras. Shade names and availability change, so check the listing for the exact colour before you buy.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High (Blue)
Best for: Length with a flexible brush
Sky High’s flexible brush is designed to reach short corner lashes, and the formula builds length without much weight. It is a good first blue mascara because the brush is easy to control.
Pros
- Easy-to-control flexible brush
- Builds noticeable length
- Affordable drugstore price
Cons
- Colour availability varies by retailer
- Not a dramatic volume formula
L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original (Cobalt Blue)
Best for: Volume in a bright blue
A classic volumising mascara that also comes in cobalt. It gives thicker lashes and a clearly blue finish.
Pros
- Thick, volumising formula
- Bright, true blue
- Easy to find
Cons
- Bigger brush can be messy on lower lashes
NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara
Best for: Bold colour at a low price
NYX’s coloured mascara line focuses on pigment. It is a budget-friendly way to try a vivid blue look.
Pros
- Strong colour payoff
- Low price
- Several shades in the line
Cons
- Less lengthening than dedicated black formulas
Essence I Love Extreme Crazy Volume (Blue)
Best for: Budget volume
Essence’s volume mascara is known for its big brush and very low price. Blue versions appear as limited or regional shades.
Pros
- Very affordable
- Big volume brush
Cons
- Blue shade is not always in stock
3INA The Color Mascara
Best for: Wide range of vivid shades
3INA offers mascara in many colours, including several blues, which makes it easy to match a specific look.
Pros
- Many blue shade options
- Vivid pigment
Cons
- Pricier than drugstore options
How to Wear Blue Mascara
- Keep the rest of the eye simple. Neutral shadow or none at all lets the blue be the focal point.
- Try it on top lashes only with black on the bottom for a subtle effect, or the reverse for a modern twist.
- Layer over black on the tips if you want depth with just a flash of colour.
- Curl first so the colour shows across the full lash length.
For a broader look at formulas, brushes and application, read our full guide to finding the best mascara. We also keep a seasonal round-up of the best blue mascaras of the year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does blue mascara suit brown eyes?
Yes. Blue contrasts with the warm tones in brown eyes, which can make them look brighter. Cobalt and navy are especially flattering.
Is blue mascara good for everyday wear?
Navy is subtle enough for most settings because it looks close to black at a distance. Brighter blues work better as a statement look.
How do I remove blue mascara?
The same way as black: micellar water for washable formulas, or an oil-based remover for waterproof ones. Hold the pad on the lashes before wiping to avoid rubbing.
Conclusion
Blue mascara is a low-risk way to experiment with colour. Start with navy if you want something wearable, move to cobalt for more impact, and choose a formula with the brush type you already like. Keep the rest of your eye makeup simple and let the colour do the work.
